Recently I talked about the combat presumption and how this can be a huge advantage in proving part of what you need to have a disability service connected. In this post, we will:
Go a little more in depth on exactly who qualifies for the combat presumption,
Give some examples of enemy engagements that may or may not qualify, and
Suggest some additional evidence to trigger the VA’s duty to apply this presumption in your favor.
Must be in combat to trigger the presumption
This presumption does not apply to all veterans for all events that happened throughout their military career. The in-service occurrence or aggravation of an injury or disease must be during the course of combat for the presumption to apply. Similarly, a veteran who engaged in combat does not get the benefit of the presumption for all incidents that happened during the course of his military service. Instead, he can only apply the presumption for injuries or aggravations during hostile encounters with the enemy.
Remember why we have the presumption in the first place. It is not to give a special benefit to combat veterans. Rather, it is supposed to put them on equal ground with veterans whose records were not subject to the chaos of combat situations.
What Qualifies as Combat?
The first thing you must show to qualify for this presumption is that the in-service event occurred while you were “engaged in combat with the enemy.” Once you prove this, you are able to take advantage of the relaxed evidentiary standard for the “event, injury, or disease” portion of your claim.
Many times, however, the facts are not so black and white. Sometimes veterans seek to have the combat presumption applied because they were in a combat zone, but that is generally insufficient to trigger the lower evidentiary standard of 38 U.S.C.S sec. 1154(b) and 38 C.F.R. sec. 3.304 (d) & (f). Likewise, a veteran will probably not meet the “combat” definition where personal harm was a mere possibility because of nearby action by an enemy force.
Courts have held that evidence of mortars directed at a military installation does not meet the required standard unless the mortar impacts were close to the veteran or caused casualties. In a case with somewhat similar facts, where the veteran was stationed at an air base during enemy attacks, the court held that this could be evidence of combat. In sum, the “combat” finding is very fact intensive and requires the VA to review allrelevant evidence and make assessments as to the credibility and probative value of that evidence.
How to Prove Combat with the Enemy
As I mentioned above, the particular facts of your combat situation are the focus when VA is deciding whether the combat presumption should apply. So, you need to develop and present these facts as best you can. The relaxed “combat presumption” standard is what you are trying to get applied, but there is no relaxed standard on the threshold question of whether you had combat service.
While VA must give you the benefit of the doubt as with other issues in your claim, it is best if you have evidence to support your statement that you were in fact in combat when the injury or aggravation occurred. If you have service records indicating combat, that is usually all you will need.
This can be in the form of military awards, decorations or citations (i.e., Purple Heart, Combat Action Badge, Combat Infantry Badge, etc.). A combat military occupational specialty can also be
enough. Evidence of hazard duty pay or buddy statements from others in your unit can also support your own statements.
Do I Need an Attorney if I Can Get the Combat Presumption?
As I said in the earlier post on the combat presumption, proving the injury or aggravation occurred in combat is only part of what you need to prove service connection. You still need evidence of a current disability and nexus between that disability and the in service event.
Also, you may need help if the VA does not properly apply or weigh the evidence to determine if the combat presumption is applicable. The VA has a duty to assist, which includes telling you the sort of evidence that will support your claim of combat incurrence. But, then again, if VA did that correctly every time, there would be no need for blogs such as this one.
Travis Studdard is an attorney who focuses on representing veterans in VA disability compensation claims. He regularly writes about issues that are important to veterans and their families.
You can subscribe to his Veterans Disability channel on YouTube.
This is a great group of people who really care about your well being. They all treated me as though I was family and helped me with my work comp case in more ways than the average would have.Thank you Jason and Thank you Tina! For doing an awesome job.
I am a Veteran of United States Air Force and was awarded my first 30% in 1996 and have been fighting for my rating for 26 years I came to Perkins and Studdard in 2019 while my mom was in a terrible incident and was given to much anesthesia and through GODS Grace she was spared her life, She is disabled since 2018 and I have been struggling with my life and issues and yet I didn’t call the law firm every 10 minutes or call being rude anytime, I mentioned this as I got to know Jessica more than just a phone call and Mr Studdard was always available when not working on other cases or in court, They always called back and Never had to do a call back, My Review is Simple in Life there peaks and valleys and it doesn’t stop because you have issues, Perkins & Studdard took my case in 2019 in 2021 I received my 100% from VA, I Was Never Rude, I was Never Promised Success, I Was Never Lied too and I was Always Treated with Respect, Friendliness, and Kindness the Real Stuff not a (Money Thing) If You want a firm that Cares about the Client and will work on your case even through a pandemic, Will not lie, will not promise anything will communicate your case and will Give you their Best ALWAYS THIS IS THE Best Law Firm for VETS HANDS DOWN Perkins and Studdard THERE IS NO OTHER 100% we had 5 calls Total Case That’s Taking Care Of Business
Jason and his paralegal Lisa were on point and on top of their game when it came to handling my worker's comp. injury case. I tried going it alone and the insurance carrier pushed me around. They denied extra physical therapy. They denied injections the doctor recommended to ease my pain. When I turned my case over to Jason things turned around, QUICK. They were at all times attentive and on top of my case. I cannot recommend Jason and his staff enough. If you are hurt at work, this is the firm you want on YOUR side.
Jason Perkins, was my lawyer in a workers comp. case, my case has settled now, and I am very happy for all Jason and his office hard work on my case, he was always there to help me out with any questions that I had or help I needed. Jason is a excellent lawyer and if I ever need another one I would only go to Perkins,Because I believe they would be able to help me in any situation I am in need of..
I recommend Perkins Law Firm. Everyone I came in contact with there was very nice. Kim was very helpful and any time I had a question she made sure I got an answer. Ann Margaret really took the time to explain things to me.
I understand you want your VA claim to be done as quickly as possible. But remember the ultimate goal – to win your VA disability compensation claim.
You may eventually get there on your own, but it may be after a series of decisions by the Regional Office and Board of Veterans Appeals. Sometimes claims are appealed and remanded several times, which can cause a claim to drag on for years. If you are interested in avoiding unnecessary delay in your claim and want to do everything you can to maximize your chances of success, it is probably a good idea for you to consult with an accredited veterans disability attorney.
We would be happy to talk to you. If you would like a free consultation with our Perkins Studdard veterans disability attorneys just click here or give us a call to begin the process.